Picture supply: Getty Pictures
Lloyds Banking Group (LSE:LLOY) shares are in an attention-grabbing place proper now. The inventory’s achieved effectively in 2024, climbing round 14%.
Going into 2025 nonetheless, the specter of potential legal responsibility regarding automotive loans has been weighing on the Lloyds share value. So how ought to buyers take into consideration the inventory when it comes to valuation?
Financial institution shares in 2024
Generally, UK banks have achieved effectively relative to the remainder of the FTSE 100 in 2024. Barclays has seen its share value climb virtually 70% for the reason that begin of the yr and NatWest‘s up greater than 80%.
In comparison with this, a 14% acquire for Lloyds shares doesn’t appear so spectacular. And a have a look at the valuation multiples at which the shares have been buying and selling offers a good suggestion about why.
Lloyds vs. Barclays vs. NatWest P/B a number of 2024
Created at TradingView
All the banks commerce at greater price-to-book (P/B) multiples than they did initially of the yr. However each Barclays and NatWest have seen a lot higher enlargement than Lloyds.
This can be a signal buyers really feel much less optimistic about Lloyds in comparison with different UK banks now than they did again in January. And it’s not that tough to see why.
Automobile loans
An investigation into practices round promoting automotive loans appears to be like set to generate substantial liabilities for lenders. And Lloyds is far more uncovered to this trade than Barclays or NatWest.
The size of the menace isn’t presently clear, however the highest estimates are round £3.9bn. A method of that is within the context of the dividends the financial institution pays its shareholders.
Banking’s a cyclical trade, so shareholder distributions differ from yr to yr. However during the last decade, Lloyds has returned a complete of £13.9bn.
Lloyds Banking Group dividends paid to shareholders 2015-24
Created at TradingView
On this context, a £3.9bn fantastic appears to be like like quite a bit – it’s greater than 25% of the dividends the corporate’s paid out within the final decade. However the query is whether or not the present share value already components this in.
Is the inventory a discount?
Lloyds presently has a market-cap of round £33bn. So if buyers obtain £10bn in dividends (the quantity from the final 10 years minus the fantastic) within the subsequent decade, that will indicate a median yield of round 3%.
That doesn’t appear like an apparent discount. However I’ve made a few pessimistic assumptions which are price noting to attempt to go away the form of margin of security I search for in an funding.
One is I’m taking a excessive estimate for the dimensions of the potential automotive mortgage legal responsibility. It’s actually doable that the eventual consequence might be higher than this for Lloyds.
One other is I’m assuming the subsequent decade can be roughly just like the earlier one when it comes to dividends. Buyers would possibly assume greater rates of interest ought to lead to higher returns from banks.
2025 outlook
Given the automotive mortgage uncertainty, I don’t see Lloyds shares as an apparent shopping for alternative to ponder. However I additionally don’t assume buyers who personal the inventory ought to essentially be in a rush to contemplate promoting.
Regardless of lagging its friends in 2024, the Lloyds share value has nonetheless managed a 14% acquire. I feel it’s roughly pretty valued the place it’s at round 55p.
