Picture supply: Getty Photos
December 2023 was a contented time for the Lloyds Banking Group (LSE:LLOY) share worth. After buying and selling decrease for many of the 12 months, the FTSE 100 financial institution shot greater final month as worries over the UK economic system — and the knock-on impact this might have on excessive road banks — sharply receded.
This meant Lloyds shares rose 3.8% in worth in 2023 in consequence. But regardless of December’s Santa Rally the corporate nonetheless provides glorious all-round worth.
The financial institution’s price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio sits at simply 6.6 occasions for 2024. That is nicely beneath the FTSE index’s ahead common of 11 occasions. In the meantime, its dividend yield of 6.6% smashes the three.8% common for different Footsie shares.
So is now time to purchase the agency for my Shares and Shares ISA? My reply to this easy query is an emphatic ‘no’. Not solely do I believe Lloyds’ share worth may proceed to crumble within the new 12 months, I believe it may stay locked in its long-term downtrend.
Listed here are simply three the explanation why I’m avoiding the Black Horse Financial institution proper now.
1. Falling NIMs
Hopes of rate of interest cuts by the Financial institution of England (BoE) have helped cyclical shares like this rise lately. Within the case of banking shares, decrease charges may assist these companies keep away from extra thumping mortgage impairments.
The difficulty is that charge reductions will even adversely have an effect on their internet curiosity margins (NIMs). These are key profitability metrics that measure the distinction between the curiosity banks pay savers and what they cost debtors.
With rates of interest now anticipated to fall as quickly because the spring, Lloyds may discover it exhausting to generate any form of earnings progress if you additionally think about level quantity two.
2. Powerful financial circumstances
The UK economic system is broadly tipped to carry out weakly subsequent 12 months, no matter rate of interest actions. So Lloyds — which has already put aside £2.4bn for the reason that begin of 2022 to cowl dangerous loans — would possibly proceed to rack up painful impairments.
The BoE has in truth sliced down its progress forecasts for 2024. It now expects Britain’s economic system to flatline this 12 months. If this gloomy omen proves right, the nation’s banks are additionally more likely to witness poor demand for his or her monetary merchandise.
I’m involved that Britain’s economic system may stay weak for a while too. Structural points like low productiveness, labour shortages, and commerce frictions additionally pose a rising long-term risk to financial progress.
3. Mounting competitors
One thing Lloyds has in its favour is its distinctive model recognition. Having a model that customers really feel they will belief is an particularly potent weapon in an business the place you take care of individuals’s cash.
However regardless of this benefit, the financial institution nonetheless has a bloody struggle on its arms to retain clients. The monetary providers business is changing into more and more fragmented and challenger and digital banks are rising their buyer bases quickly, because of their dynamic on-line fashions and market-leading merchandise.
Worryingly for Lloyds, competitors is very fierce within the mortgage sector, a key income driver for the agency. Banks and constructing societies are aggressively slashing charges proper now, and Lloyds now finds itself means a great distance down the ‘finest purchase’ tables. This might change into the norm throughout its product courses.
